Favorites include Werewolf, Superfight, Concept, The Resistance, Coup, Love Letter and Saboteur. Last week we added A Fake Artist Goes to New York and Spyfall 2. Old favorites like Dutch Blitz and Clue sometimes show up on the table as well. Most of the games for a smaller number of players are not played as often because they like to play together and rarely split the group into 2. We recently divided our game bags into 4 players or less and 4 players and above bags, but then we went on vacation and pulled a few out and messed it up. I need to reorganize them soon.
Even with all the scheduling annoyances, it's been a good experience and I'm glad we started it.